The Lyall Hotel Melbourne, Melbourne

The hotel offers spacious, clean, and well-appointed rooms but could benefit from updating. The service is fabulous and accommodating, going above and beyond with thoughtful gestures. Its location is ideal for accessing South Yarra's attractions easily, although the technology in the room could use improvement. The dining options are interesting but could have a more varied selection of lighter choices. The facilities provided are satisfactory.

Staying at the hotel was a mix of comfort and disappointment. The rooms were cozy with cute little balconies, but the front desk service fell short of expectations. The very helpful and friendly staff made up for some of the flaws, providing a decent stay overall.

My stay at the hotel was a mix of positives and negatives. The rooms were spacious and well-equipped with all the amenities I needed, but the shower setup was a bit inconvenient, leading to water leaking and flooding the bathroom floor. The balcony, though cute, was unuseable due to nearby construction noise and lack of privacy. The staff, however, were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout my visit.

I had a pleasant stay at the hotel, especially enjoying the spacious and comfortable rooms. The staff were courteous and attentive, ensuring a great night at the Lyall Hotel. The location was fantastic, offering easy access to nearby restaurants and the South Yarra station. However, the dining options were limited, and some construction nearby affected the luxury feel of the location.

Staying at the hotel was a mixed experience. While the rooms were very large and well-designed, they appeared worn and dated with very few outlets and outdated amenities. On the bright side, the service was terrific, with staff going the extra mile to accommodate our requests. The location was superb, offering easy access to favorite restaurants in South Yarra. However, the dining experience was very average, especially considering the high prices. Despite some drawbacks, the hotel provides good value for money overall.

The Lyall Hotel is a great find, centrally located with superb service and delicious dining options. The spacious and clean rooms are perfect for a comfortable stay, but some areas could use a bit of a refresh.

My stay at the hotel was comfortable and elegant, with rooms providing an ashtray for balcony use, a 24-hour lobby, and great value. However, the room was not ready by 1 pm and was quite dark at times.

The hotel had some drawbacks with worn-out and dated rooms, but it was a pleasant stay overall with a spa bath included. The service was helpful and accommodating, especially in addressing concerns. The location was wonderful, offering easy access to favorite restaurants in South Yarra. The dining was a bit pricey for what was served. However, the facilities were satisfactory.

The hotel rooms were large and well-designed, but the shower setup caused water leakage and the balcony was unusable. The service was excellent, efficient, and went above and beyond. The location was superb, close to public transportation and boutique shops. The dining options were delicious but limited. Overall, a great stay with a few drawbacks.